South Coast DTP Complaints Procedure

Scope of this procedure

  1. The SCDTP is a collaboration between the following partner Universities:
  1. The SCDTP disburses ESRC and institutional funds through the award of Masters and doctoral studentships, and through needs-based training and development for award holders and other PGR students at partner Universities
  2. The SCDTP is committed to operating a fair, efficient and transparent review and selection process for the funding that it offers on a competitive basis, including Masters/ PhD studentships, additional funding for current students and any extensions to studentships.

For applicants for the SCDTP studentship competition:

  1. If you are dissatisfied with the way in which your application for a studentship has been handled, this procedure provides guidance on how to raise a complaint and/or appeal a funding decision. This only applies to those whose applications were submitted by one of the partner Universities. If you were not nominated to the SCDTP Selection Committee, any appeal or complaint relating to the handling of your application must be directed to the University through which you applied for funding.
  2. Separate procedures exist for appeals or complaints relating to decisions relating to admissions to a programme. Please see the graduate admissions complaints and appeals procedures available on the institutional websites of the partner Universities.

For current studentship award holders:

  1. If you are a current award-holder, and are dissatisfied with: (a) the way in which your application for additional DTP funding has been handled by the SCDTP, (b) any service offered by the SCDTP, or (c) the actions or behaviour of a member of SCDTP staff, this procedure provides guidance on how to raise a complaint and/or appeal a funding decision.
  2. This procedure does not cover the following: supervision; institutional resources; the consideration of interruptions to study and upgrades; academic progression. These and any other issue not directly relating to services or the award of funding by the SCDTP should be addressed to the home University.

Definitions

  1. This procedure applies to i) applicants for the SCDTP studentship competition, and ii) current SCDTP award-holders (‘Applicant’).
  2. An appeal is a formal request for reconsideration of a decision on a funding application or the wording/ terms/ conditions of an offer (‘Appeal’).
  3. Appeals will only be considered on the following grounds:

i)  Procedural irregularity, where an Applicant believes that the SCDTP has not adhered to its published guidance for awarding SCDTP funding;

ii) Extenuating circumstances, which, for good reason, were not included in the original application, and which could have been material to the decision-making process. Applicants will need to provide details giving the reasons as to why this information was not disclosed at the time of application;

iii) Bias or perception of bias in the decision-making process. Applicants will need to provide specific examples with supporting documentation to evidence this.

 

  1. A complaint, for the purposes of this process, constitutes an expression of dissatisfaction by the Applicant regarding any service offered by the SCDTP, or regarding the actions or behaviour of a member of SCDTP staff (‘Complaint’).
  2. There is no right of appeal or complaint over matters of academic judgement.

 

General Principles

  1. Information about a Complaint or Appeal will only be shared with other parties where disclosure is necessary in order to ensure a fair investigation (e.g. the Applicant’s identity will normally be disclosed to a person or body who is the subject of the complaint or whose decision is being appealed).
  2. All parties involved in a Complaint or Appeal are required to act reasonably, fairly and courteously towards each other and to respect the SCDTP’s procedures.
  3. Anyone involved in a Complaint or Appeal may act through a representative who should normally be a member of one of the universities in the SCDTP, or a family member, or trade union officer.
  4. Time limits should normally be met by all parties. Time limits may be extended by the relevant decision-maker where it is necessary to do so in order to ensure a fair outcome.
  5. Complaints and Appeals that are anonymous or made by third parties will only be considered in exceptional circumstances where there are compelling reasons to do so.
  6. The SCDTP may decline to consider a Complaint or Appeal where the matters in dispute are currently being considered or have been decided by an external body, such as a court or tribunal.
  7. If the SCDTP Director is conflicted, or is otherwise unable to determine the matter, an appropriate substitute will be appointed who will usually be a senior academic at one of the universities in the SCDTP. The person determining the Complaint or Appeal shall not have any conflict of interest in the matter.
  8. The SCDTP may decline to consider the Complaint or Appeal if it is trivial or repeats a Complaint or Appeal that has already been made.
  9. For all other Complaints or Appeals, the SCDTP may take any steps that are considered necessary to investigate, including calling on any person to provide specialist assistance. The SCDTP will usually send details of the matter to anyone who is a subject of the Complaint, or the original decision-maker(s) (for Appeals of funding decisions).
  10. You may withdraw your Complaint or Appeal at any time; the SCDTP may however decide to continue the investigation if it is appropriate and fair to do so.

 

Procedure

Level 1: Informal resolution

  1. Before raising a Complaint or Appeal, you should contact the SCDTP Manager (J.Lin@soton.ac.uk) and/or Director (A.Vlachantoni@soton.ac.uk) to explore concerns and, if possible, resolve the matter informally.

Level 2: Formal consideration by the SCDTP Senior Management Team

  1. If you are dissatisfied with the outcome of Level 1, you may submit a Complaint or Appeal for formal investigation to the SCDTP Manager (J.Lin@soton.ac.uk). Your formal complaint should describe:
  1. The SCDTP Manager will normally acknowledge the complaint within 5 working days and refer it to the SCDTP Director or Deputy Director from your home University. You should expect a response within fifteen working days, or a statement of the timescale for a full response. Please be aware that investigation of complaints may involve multiple parties, and so may take some time. Any delay will be explained and you will be kept informed of progress.
  2. Care will be taken to ensure that anyone who is the subject of a complaint, or has been involved in a complaint at an earlier stage, is not involved in investigating it.

Level 3: Formal consideration by an independent person

  1. If you are dissatisfied with the outcome of Level 2, you may submit your Complaint or Appeal to the SCDTP Manager (J.Lin@soton.ac.uk) for investigation by a senior member of staff at a SCDTP University. This person will be appointed in consultation with the SCDTP Steering Group. You should include:
  1. Requests to review the outcomes of Level 2 investigations will be considered in terms of whether any of these conditions are met:
  1. The SCDTP Manager will normally acknowledge the complaint within 5 working days, and provide a schedule for further responses. You will be kept informed of progress.
  2. You will be notified of the outcome of the investigation of the complaint at Level 3 in writing.
  3. In the decision letter, the DTP will set out the decision on the Complaint or Appeal, the reasons for the decision and any recommendations.
  4. The SCDTP will also notify the outcome to anyone who is a subject of the Complaint (for funding complaints) or the original decision-maker(s) (for funding Appeals) and anyone in the member institutions that need to be made aware of it.

Last updated November 2026